What You Should Know Before Buying a Used American Girl® Doll

There’s many great reasons to buy a secondhand American Girl doll. Perhaps you are searching for a retired doll, such as Caroline, Elizabeth, or Nellie. Maybe you are hoping to save some money. Or, maybe you are looking for a specific doll to replace a favorite childhood toy. Regardless the reasons, it’s worth doing a little research before you jump into the secondhand AG market. So, don’t buy a used doll without reviewing my tried-and-true tips for a successful purchase!

Please note that this post contains affiliate links which allow me to earn a small commission when a purchase is made at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read more here.

I was a childhood fan of Pleasant Company, so I when I became interested in collecting again as an adult I was amazed at the great deals to be found on the used market. My last memories of American Girl were of everything being sooo expensive so it was amazing to get any doll with an outfit for $50-60 on eBay.

Now, I quickly realized that the used market isn’t all bargains. In fact, it’s actually quite competitive and the “good stuff” can be rather pricey.

Just browse through ebay listings for complete Pleasant Company outfits for Felicity, Kirsten, or Addy to get a taste of the current prices for top collector picks (such as early Pleasant Company items and rare dolls like GOTY #4 and Nellie). Retired dolls many end up costing a lot more than brand-new dolls in many cases.

With the 40th Anniversary of American Girl this year (2026), the secondhand market is even crazier! Prices are high, there’s lots of interest, and collectors have been willing to pay some truly shocking pieces for toys are not even technically “rare”.

If you are into collecting (or just snagging a few favorites you missed out on during childhood), you will want to shop with eyes wide open. Paying premium prices is one thing when you are getting what you expect, but if you overpay for a doll that turns out to be damaged, full of funky odors, or defective, it can be a real bummer.

I’ve ran into plenty of snags when buying used dolls and clothing, whether over the internet or locally.

While this list of shopping tips and tricks is by no means exhaustive (it seems there’s always some new problem to discover when purchasing collectibles and toys!), it’s a thorough starting place and will help you avoid many worst-case scenarios.

This list can be used for online purchases and local purchases. The more questions you can ask, the better!

What You Should Do Before Buying a Used Doll

Before you buy a used doll, do these things first!

Check Return Policies

Check return policies before you buy. I like to quickly ask myself the following questions:

• Can I return this? (FB marketplace deals, thrift stores, garage sales obviously will be no)
• Do I want to ship this back if I don’t like it? (even if you are allowed to return to eBay, this can still be inconvenient)
• Is this something I truly want or is it just “an amazing deal”?

Check the Description

It might seem obvious, but read the description closely first. Take note of any damage listed, what is or is not included in the purchase, and any shipping or purchasing information.

Carefully look through the photographs too. I suggest viewing photos on a desktop if you can. Phone photos are small, so it’s easy to completely obvious flaws.

If you are purchasing in-person, take note of any damage or odors as you inspect the doll.

In the next sections, I’ll detail some things you should look for as you inspect a doll. If you can’t find your answers in the description or photos online (or sometimes even if you can), you should ask the seller a question to clarify.

It’s very important to get things in writing in case you later need to claim a return (this is mostly for eBay). If a seller has confidently asserted that the doll is odor-free, without stains, etc and it turns out to not be the case, then you will be able to make a stronger case for a return.

You can also ask questions if you are buying locally on Facebook Marketplace. Good deals tend to fly quickly, so you might miss out while waiting for a response, so this is up to you. You can also inspect the item at pickup and decline to purchase, but some sellers react poorly to this so it’s not my favorite strategy.

Some sellers don’t wish to take the time to review their item and accurately answer questions. That’s perfectly fine, but I personally skip these listings. If a seller doesn’t want to answer preliminary questions, they may not be willing to help you in the case the item is not as described.

Check for Odors

Odors can be challenging to remove from dolls. Ask sellers if there are any musty or smoke smells.

Smoke damage in particular is a big red flag, since it may cause damage beyond odor.

Note: Some older vinyl dolls (like the first generation of PC/AG mini dolls) can develop a funky crayon odor from the vinyl composition. Some people won’t even notice this, but I do like to ask in case it’s strong and I would rather return the purchase.

Inspect Eyes

Check photos to be sure that the doll is shown both with eyes open and eyes closed.

When the eyes are open look for silver eye. This often starts slowly, so inspect photos carefully.

With the eyelids closed, check for signs of paint or “makeup”. Young girls often experiment with haircuts and makeup on their dolls. Sometimes this has been done with permanent materials.

Also check fingers and toes for nail polish. All limbs should be fully visible in the description photos.

Check Neck Stamp

The neck stamp is essential to determining the age of the doll. You can find plenty of photos online that can help to determine the estimated age of a doll based on the neck stamp.

If you are interested in only collecting first edition Pleasant Company dolls, you will have a lot to learn to reliably identify these. Oftentimes sellers will list things as “first”, “first edition”, “first run” etc. and the dolls are nothing of the kind.

Don’t take someone’s word for it–do your research, ask questions, and only purchase when confident.

The First Five Dolls: Each of the first five historical Pleasant Company dolls (Kirsten, Samantha, Molly, Addy, Felicity) have different characteristics and changes that were made throughout the years that can help with identification.

Look for Stains and Mold

I generally inquire if there are stains or mold present. I feel that it’s important to have an answer to this question in writing, since stains and mold can be hidden to missed.

For mold: look for fuzziness, white gunk, green or black fuzziness, and wet spots on the doll. Mold can kind of be a tough one to spot. You can browse through queries on Reddit and Facebook to see examples.

I’ve seen cases where a moldy doll is restored with lots of effort, which is great, but I personally would never be able to trust that it was completely free from mold. For me, the risk that the mold would spread to other dolls or outfits in my collection is too great a risk.

Anyone attempting to clean a moldy doll should absolutely research and adhere to the strictest safety precautions as well, as mold exposure can be quite dangerous to your health!

Be careful how you store your doll collections. Store in temperature-controlled environment (no garages, attics, or sheds). It’s best to avoid basements or any area of your home that could be high-moisture (such as closet that is adjacent to a bedroom).

When purchasing used dolls or clothing, I watch for signs of mouse activity too. Droppings, chew marks etc. A pile of doll clothes that looks gross, probably is. I once sifted through a box of doll clothes that had mouse droppings throughout. Yuck!

Look for Haircuts & Bald Patches

It can be tough to discern haircuts from photos, but do your best to check.

As I understand it, dolls like Josefina who came with a braid hairstyle would have been trimmed at the factory after the braid was complete. This means the hair should look a little uneven when it is out of the braid. If it looks perfectly straight, that might turn out to be evidence of a haircut.

Carefully check dolls with pin curls such as Elizabeth Cole or Marie-Grace. These face-framing curls often get combed out and are hidden, but still present. Sometimes though, they were cut at some point. If so, that is damage you will want to factor into your decision to purchase a doll or not.

Research Known Issues

If you are on the hunt for a specific doll, it’s worth doing some research and seeing if you uncover any known issues. Sometimes just searching the doll’s name on Reddit can be helpful.

For instance, there are many Nellie dolls that have turned orange over time. This can be fixed through the doll hospital, but it can be costly.

Check for Restoration

If a doll looks “too good to be true”, it just may be. A seller may have restored the doll to attempt to sell for a higher value. Some sellers repair silver eyes, straighten hair, or even carefully repaint face paint.

There is nothing wrong with doing these repairs, but they should be disclosed to avoid confusion.

Check Tags on the Doll’s Outfit

Never assume a pile of doll clothing that looks authentic actually is. In the early Pleasant Company days, sewing patterns were published that you could use to make some of the historical doll’s most popular looks. Many mothers and grandmothers made up these patterns and created some impressive reproductions.

To add to the confusion, occasionally PC clothing does not have a tag sewn in. In that case you probably have to use context clues–if the item is part of a collection that otherwise appears authentic, then it’s likely fine. If it’s a single piece for sale on ebay or something like that then it may be harder to tell.

What are your top questions you ask before purchasing a used doll?
Share in the comments, I’d love to hear your thoughts!