Crumbl Cookie Recipes To Bake at Home!

If you love eating Crumbl Cookies, these Crumbl copycat cookie recipes are for you. Some of these recipes will make a whole batch of cookies and others will show you how to make just one large cookie (perfect for indulging a craving!).

A collage of six different cookie photos with the words, "Crumbl Copycat Recipes"

As I’ve been making more Crumbl Copycat recipes, I wanted to start a list of all the recipes in one place. Though there is just a handful of recipes here at the moment, I’m working on several new copycat/inspired-by recipes that I’m excited to share.

What Do You Prefer? A recipe that makes 1-2 Crumbl Cookies or a recipe that makes 6-12 cookies?
I’d love to hear your thoughts!

What are Crumbl Cookies you ask? This fun bakery is over 300 stores strong (and growing) and is hugely popular for their over-the-top indulgent giant cookies made in fun flavors like Mint Chip Ice Cream, Boston Cream Pie, Lemon Bar, Key Lime Pie, Cookies & Cream Milkshake and so many more!

Because they utilize a rotating flavor menu with five fresh flavors each week (plus Milk Chocolate Chip), you are never quite sure if/when your favorite flavor will return. Enter, copycat recipes!

Of course, sometimes it’s just less-expensive and more convenient to whip up a cookie (or a whole batch) yourself and that’s another great reason to try baking your favorite cookies.

Since Crumbl Cookies has over 200 cookie flavors to hit their rotating menu (in fact, here’s the whole list of Crumbl flavors), there is plenty of inspiration for copycat cookie recipes! In fact, it’s almost overwhelming keeping track of all the recipe tests and works-in-progress I have going in my kitchen.

Question time! What are your favorite flavors and what do you want to see a copycat recipe for? Let me know!

Peanut Butter Bar Cookies

This recipe for Crumbl Peanut Butter Bar Cookies might just be my favorite. I mean, chocolate + peanut butter is always the right choice and this chewy peanut butter oatmeal cookie topped with fudge-y homemade chocolate buttercream is a straight up win.

A chocolate-frosted peanut butter bar cookie with a bite removed on a white plate.

Crumbl Classic Pink Sugar Cookie Recipe!

The classic recipe! Since Crumbl is no longer serving their Pink Sugar Cookie every week (tears!), all the more reason to whip up a batch of Classic Pink Sugar Cookies at home. This easy recipe will make 12 large cookies and is super easy. It requires just one bowl and zero chill time before baking. I include notes for making a thicker layer (if desired) of pink frosting on top of these soft and chewy cookies.

A parchment-lined cookie sheet filled with pink-frosted sugar cookies and a knife with frosting on it.

New York Cheesecake Cookies

These New York Cheesecake Cookies are like cheesecake, but in reverse! I amped up the flavor of the cheesecake with a no-bake cheesecake topping (instead of an overly sweet frosting-type topping) and plenty of graham cracker crumbs in the cookie base.

A graham cracker cookie with cheesecake frosting, a sprinkle of graham cracker crust, and a bite removed.

Blueberry Muffin Cookies

This all-new Crumbl Blueberry Muffin Cookies recipe starts off with a muffin mix (yes!) which provides that blueberry flavor throughout the whole cookie. These are soft, sweet, and covered in an irresistible streusel.

A stack of three blueberry muffin cookies on a stack of three white plates.

Crumbl Sugar Cookie for One

If you are feeling those Crumbl cravings, but don’t want to make a big batch of cookies, this recipe is your ticket. Make just one Crumbl Style Sugar Cookie (frosting included!) and feel free to customize your flavor choice to just vanilla or the classic almond flavor. This recipe is the same as the recipe above, but carefully edited down for a single cookie. You’ll love this quick recipe!

Swirls of homemade pink buttercream on a sugar cookie.

Crumbl Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie for One

I love the whole “cookie for one” concept since it can be hard to eat a whole batch of cookies as a single or couple. What to do with all those extra cookies?! Here, you’ll make just one Crumbl Style Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie and it’s so chewy and good. I personally feel that this recipe has more flavor and texture than the original version I imitated (which I always felt like was just a little too sweet!).

A chocolate chip cookie made with milk chocolate chips on a stack of small plates.

Crumbl Cinnamon Cookie Recipe

This recipe is so indulgent! If you aren’t up for all the extra sugar of the creamy glaze and Cinnamon Toast Sprinkle, just make these cinnamon cookies on their own. This Crumbl Cinnamon Cookie Recipe makes cookies that are soft and chewy like a good sugar cookie, but with a yummy cinnamon flavor.

A frosted cinnamon cookie with a bite removed on a scalloped plate with a sprinkle of cinnamon cereal on top.

Single Serve Peanut Butter Cookie

Sometimes a good peanut butter cookie can be hard to find! I love the base that Crumbl uses in cookies like the Peanut Butter Cookie ft. Snickers and Peanut Butter Cookie ft. Muddy Buddies so this cookie is a copycat of their yummy base cookie. Try this giant single serve Peanut Butter Cookie whenever you are craving a chewy pb cookie!

Broken peanut butter cookies stacked on each other.

Here’s the cookie compared alongside a Peanut Butter Cookie ft. Snickers from Crumbl.

I hope you found a few new Crumbl Cookies recipes you are eager to try! I love making these giant cookies, so I’m looking forward to continuing to grow this list. Yum!

More Recipes to Try

If you love making dessert at home I think you’ll love the following recipes too:

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.