No Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake Mason Jars

These No Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake Mason Jars are the perfect little individual pumpkin cheesecakes. They are made with a cream no-bake pumpkin cheesecake filling, homemade crust, and a topping of fresh whipped cream. Save oven space, prepare them ahead of time, and don’t worry about fussing with cutting a cheesecake…these lightly-spiced and ultra-creamy mini desserts are ready to serve!

I am having so much fun with creating mason jar desserts lately. They are adorable of course, but they also make hosting a gathering of family or friends (whether that’s Thanksgiving or another event) a breeze.

Whenever I can make a recipe completely ahead of time, I find myself making it again and again. Goodness knows there are enough other things to worry about once guests begin arriving for a holiday!

Why You’ll Love Making These Mini Pumpkin Cheesecakes

Easy to Serve: Cutting a cheesecake neatly is a bit of an art. Done correctly it takes time. Skip the hassle and have dessert ready to go with these individual mason jar desserts.

Ideal Portion Sizes: These modest portions are the perfect dessert serving (about a slice of pie) but still leave a little room if you want to sample other treats on Thanksgiving Day!

Make Ahead & No Oven Needed: These pumpkin cheesecakes are a no bake dessert that can be made 100% ahead of time (up to a few days in fact). Just top with a dollop of whipped cream or whipped topping right before serving. No oven space and certainly no water bath needed for this dessert.

Streamlined Method: When I first tested this recipe, I used homemade whipped cream. While you can still serve it with homemade whipped cream on party day if you want (or the stuff in a can–no judgment here), the actual recipe is now streamlined by using a quick scoop of thawed frozen whipped topping (you know the one) which yields a creamy pumpkin filling in a fraction of the time.

Perfect for Traveling: These jars are perfect for traveling. Just top them with their lids and keep chilled while traveling. Then, when ready to serve, remove the lids and top with whipping topping and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbles. No fussing with trying to pack a full-size cheesecake!

How Many Desserts Does This Recipe Make?

This recipe makes 8 Individual No Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake Mason Jars. These are 4-oz “mini” mason jars. The servings are about the same as a slice of pie and the recipe is easily doubled for more jars. The jars will be quite full (and if a spoonful remains, you know what to do), so you could also stretch the recipe to 10 jars if you like.

Some cheesecake mason jar recipes serve up their dessert in 8 oz jars, but I just found that amount to be too much. If you’d prefer larger portions though, double the recipe and serve in 8 oz jars or ramekins.

Where to Buy the Right Size Mason Jars

I like buying small 4 oz mason jars for my desserts. You can also get the “quilted” 4 oz jars which are very cute and festive too. I usually buy my jars locally versus online–they are often less expensive that way.

More Fall Recipes! Don’t forget to browse through my list of the Top Pumpkin Pie Recipes and Favorite Fall Cookie Recipes for more fall dessert ideas.

Ingredients You’ll Need:

For the Cheesecake:

• Cream Cheese: Use full-fat cream cheese for this recipe. I avoid using generic-brand cream cheese for my cheesecake recipes–a high quality brand makes a big difference in flavor!
• Powdered Sugar: A little powdered sugar (confectioner’s sugar) is ideal for blending smoothly into the filling. I didn’t try granulated, but if you are in a pinch, use your hand mixer to blend it first with the softened cream cheese for a few minutes (before adding the other ingredients) to help reduce any potential graininess.
• Brown sugar
• Pumpkin Puree: Use canned pumpkin puree and avoid the pre-spiced pumpkin pie mix. I suggest sticking with Libby’s or similar (I used a can from Aldi in one of my tests). Organic pumpkin puree tends to have more liquid and can affect the final consistency of the dessert.
• Pumpkin Pie Spice: Each pumpkin pie spice brand will have a slightly different spice mix. My preference is to make my own pumpkin pie spice mix. Taste the cheesecake layer before spooning into your jars and adjust the spice if you like.
• Ground Cinnamon
• Vanilla Extract
• Pinch of salt: regular table salt
• Thawed Frozen Whipped Topping: Yes, the stuff that goes by “Cool Whip”. Thaw it in the fridge ahead of time and don’t be tempted to thaw on the counter–it’ll turn into soup!

For the Crust:

• Graham Crackers: Use crushed regular or cinnamon graham crackers for this dessert.
• Granulated Sugar
• Unsalted butter, melted: You can melt the butter in the microwave using 10-15 second intervals. Watch for explosions!

To serve:

• Whipped Cream or Frozen Whipped Topping: Whip up homemade whipped cream to serve (I whipped up 1 cup of heavy cream to top these and had plenty for the rosettes you see in the photos) or go the quicker route and use thawed frozen whipped topping (Cool Whip).
• A few crumbles of graham crackers and some shards make a pretty presentation too! Oh–and caramel. Yeeeees.

How to Soften Cream Cheese – Microwave Version

This recipe requires softening the cream cheese to start. While there are several easy ways to soften cream cheese, I find that I never remember to remove it from the fridge soon enough in advance. Microwaving it is a quick solution.

Remove the cream cheese from all the packaging, including the foil wrapper of course. Set on a plate or in a bowl and microwave on high for 10 second intervals until softened. After each interval give the brick a little mash with a fork to distribute the heat and prevent hot spots from forming. Don’t accidentally melt the brick.

Once it’s soft, you are ready to use it in your recipe. I avoid reduced fat products here—these can do funny things to your dessert.

How to Make No Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake Mason Jars

I like to include step-by-step photos with my recipes, so this is a quick overview of how to make these mini desserts. Find the complete recipe at the end of this post!

Soften your cream cheese in a bowl (see instructions above) and beat for a minute or two with a hand mixer to ensure it’s soft and free of lumps.

Add in the remaining ingredients for the pumpkin cheesecake except for the frozen whipped topping (it’s going to smell so yummy) and beat until completely combined.

Remove the beaters, grab a spatula, and gently fold in the frozen whipped topping to the pumpkin mixture. At this point it’ll be thick, creamy, and basically irresistible. Set aside.

Mix up your crust ingredients: graham cracker crumbs, sugar, and melted butter. Distribute half the mixture onto the bottom of eight 4-oz mason jars. Wiggle the jars to even the crust.

Next, fill jars with a big spoonful of the pumpkin cheesecake filling–about halfway up the jars. You’re aiming to use about half the filling on this first layer.

Here’s a quick tip to smooth the filling: I take my spoon, gently press it down in the jar touching the outside edge and then I hold the spoon steady while I spin the jar with my opposite hand. This gives a smooth top to the dessert. Wipe away any smudges with a damp paper towel if you like.

See the before and after?

Now, layer the remaining crust mixture evenly inside each of the jars. Again, wiggling them a bit to even the crust. Add the remaining filling and repeat the smoothing technique and cleaning up the edges of the jars as needed.

To store: Chill for about four hours or until set.

For serving: I like to pipe a large rosette of whipped cream on top of each dessert. Sprinkle with some graham cracker crumbs and/or drizzle with some caramel sauce too!

More Mason Jar Desserts & Ideas

• Baby Yoda Mason Jar Pistachio Desserts
• No Bake French Silk Pie Mason Jar Desserts
• 15+ Mason Jar Crafts and Décor Ideas
• Pumpkin Pie Spice Mix in a Jar + Printable Gift Tags!